Fable 5.1 vs GPT-6 Astra vs Gemini 3.8: Same Score, Different Bill
On this page
The September 9 rematch changes the headline
Four days is a long time on an AI leaderboard. On September 5, the clean comparison was that Claude Fable 5.1 scored slightly above GPT-6 Astra while spending far more tokens. Artificial Analysis has since moved its Intelligence Index to version 4.3 and rerun the models. The current maximum-effort result is a tie: Fable 5.1 and Astra both score 53.
The bill did not tie. Artificial Analysis now reports $7.63 per task for Fable 5.1 and $3.26 for Astra. Across the full index, that is $13,128.86 versus $5,324.10. Fable produced about 78,000 output tokens per task; Astra produced about 27,000. Gemini 3.8 Flash, run at high effort rather than max, scores 41 at $1.24 per task.
That makes this a more useful buying story than the launch-week version. The frontier models can land on the same composite score and still differ by more than 2x in measured task cost. A cheaper model can also spend more tokens than its predecessor. “Price per million tokens” is only one input to the invoice.
Bottom line. Do not choose a default model from a price table or a single composite score. Compare quality, completion rate, latency, tokens per completed task, cache behavior, and access policy on the work you actually route.
Figure 1. Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index v4.3 and measured cost per task, model pages read September 9, 2026. Fable 5.1 and Astra are max-effort runs; Gemini 3.8 Flash is high effort. The effort levels are not interchangeable.
What changed since the September 5 snapshot
The earlier numbers were not invented; they were a dated snapshot of a leaderboard that has since changed methodology and coverage. They should not be silently overwritten or treated as a longitudinal performance test.
| Metric | September 5 snapshot | September 9 current page | What buyers should infer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fable 5.1 / Astra Intelligence Index | 57 / 55 | 53 / 53 | The composite was revised; this is not evidence that either model “got worse.” |
| Fable 5.1 / Astra full-index cost | $10,816 / $4,064 | $13,128.86 / $5,324.10 | Fable remains roughly 2.5x more expensive on this run. |
| Fable 5.1 / Astra total output | 160M / 49M | 188M / 60M | The verbosity gap remains large after the rerun. |
| Fable 5.1 / Astra cost ratio | 2.66x | 2.47x full index; 2.34x per task | The conclusion survives even though the inputs moved. |
| Gemini 3.8 Flash index / task cost | 47 / not normalized | 41 / $1.24 | Gemini is a different quality-cost point, not a direct flagship substitute. |
Artificial Analysis v4.3 combines ten evaluations. Its current comparison page is excellent for a same-day, same-provider view, but it is not a controlled before-and-after experiment against the September 5 version. Keep both dates in your evaluation log.
The list prices still matter — just not by themselves
Fable 5.1 and Astra share the same short-context list price: $10 per million input tokens and $50 per million output tokens. Their cache economics and long-context terms differ. Gemini 3.8 Flash is dramatically cheaper through the end of 2026, then its launch price doubles unless Google extends the promotion.
| Model | Input / output per 1M | Cached input | Cache write | Context / max output | Access |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claude Fable 5.1 | $10 / $50 | $0.25 | $12.50 | 1M / 128K | Public API, with safety fallbacks for flagged domains |
| GPT-6 Astra | $10 / $50 | $1.00 | $12.50 | about 1M / 128K | Public API; long-context tier is $20 input, $2 cached input, $25 cache write and $75 output |
| Gemini 3.8 Flash | $0.75 / $3.75 through Dec 31; $1.50 / $7.50 from Jan 1 | $0.075 during promo | provider terms apply | about 1M / 65K | Public Gemini API |
Prices are first-party API list prices read September 9, 2026. Partner clouds can bill differently. Recheck the vendor page before committing a budget.
The most important hidden line is the one your workload repeats. A cache-heavy agent may favor Fable because its cache read is one quarter of Astra’s standard cached-input rate. A long-context Astra request can move into the higher tier, where input, cached input, cache writes, and output all rise. Neither fact tells you the winner without a trace of your own prompts.
Here is a deliberately simple worked example: 1M uncached input tokens, 10M cache-read tokens, and 0.5M output tokens, before any long-context uplift.
Fable 5.1 = (1 × $10) + (10 × $0.25) + (0.5 × $50) = $37.50
Astra = (1 × $10) + (10 × $1.00) + (0.5 × $50) = $45.00
Gemini = (1 × $0.75) + (10 × $0.075) + (0.5 × $3.75) = $3.38That example makes Fable cheaper than Astra. The independent evaluation makes Fable more expensive because it emits far more output. Both can be true. Workload shape decides.
A tie is not a capability profile
The shared score of 53 compresses ten different evaluations into one number. The underlying results point to different defaults.
Figure 2. Selected components from the current Artificial Analysis v4.3 comparison, read September 9, 2026. Higher is better. These are independent runs under the same comparison framework, not vendor launch claims.
| Evaluation | GPT-6 Astra | Claude Fable 5.1 | Edge |
|---|---|---|---|
| AA-Briefcase | 1,562 | 1,662 | Fable |
| GDPval-AA | 1,580 | 1,764 | Fable |
| AutomationBench | 68 | 59 | Astra |
| Terminal-Bench 4 | 59 | 52 | Astra |
| SciCode | 56 | 63 | Fable |
| Humanity’s Last Exam | 55 | 59 | Fable |
| GDP.pdf | 31 | 26 | Astra |
| CritPt | 32 | 30 | Astra |
| Omniscience | 43 | 43 | Tie |
| Long-context reasoning | 81 | 85 | Fable |
This is the practical split. Fable leads the current comparison on professional knowledge, science coding, hard reasoning, and long-context work. Astra leads automation, terminal tasks, and document-heavy evaluation, while reaching the same composite with fewer output tokens and less measured decode time per task: about 492 seconds versus 734 seconds for Fable. Artificial Analysis excludes time to first token from this timing metric, so it should not be read as end-to-end wall-clock latency.
Do not turn those averages into universal routing rules. A nine-point lead on AutomationBench does not guarantee a nine-point lead in your deployment pipeline. It tells you which model deserves the first controlled trial.
Gemini 3.8 Flash has an upgrade tax
Gemini is the low-cost branch of this comparison, but 3.8 is not simply “3.7, only better.” On Artificial Analysis at high effort, 3.8 gains two index points while using more reasoning, more output, and more time.
| Artificial Analysis, high effort | Gemini 3.8 Flash | Gemini 3.7 Flash |
|---|---|---|
| Intelligence Index | 41 | 39 |
| Cost per task | $1.24 | $0.93 |
| Full-index cost | $1,622.73 | $1,083.69 |
| Output tokens per task | 71K | 58K |
| Reasoning tokens per task | 43K | 21K |
| Total output tokens | 172M | 104M |
| Output speed | 273 tokens/s | 297 tokens/s |
| Median time to first token | 14.26s | 9.92s |
| Time per task | 241.19s | 188.85s |
The upgrade buys capability, but the measured task cost rises about 33% and time per task about 28%. Keep 3.7 in the routing test if its two-point deficit does not change your completion rate.
The bill is the result of behavior, not just rates
Figure 3. Current Artificial Analysis task cost and output-token intensity, read September 9, 2026. Fable 5.1 and Astra are max effort; Gemini 3.8 Flash is high effort.
| Model | Intelligence Index | Cost per task | Output tokens per task | Total cost of current index | Time per task |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claude Fable 5.1 | 53 | $7.63 | 78K | $13,128.86 | 733.67s |
| GPT-6 Astra | 53 | $3.26 | 27K | $5,324.10 | 492.35s |
| Gemini 3.8 Flash | 41 | $1.24 | 71K | $1,622.73 | 241.19s |
Three conclusions survive the update:
- Fable and Astra are peers on the composite, not on consumption. Fable costs 2.34x more per measured task and emits almost 3x as many output tokens.
- Gemini’s low price absorbs verbosity. It emits more output per task than Astra but still costs less than half as much per task.
- A public benchmark cannot price failure on your work. If Fable closes materially more of your hardest jobs on the first try, the human time saved can erase its token premium. Measure the completed task, including retries and review.
Access policy is part of the product
The launch-week coverage blurred base models and gated cyber programs. They are not the same offer.
- Fable 5.1 is publicly available. Anthropic says requests that trigger certain cyber safeguards can fall back to Claude Opus 4.8, while some biological-risk requests can route to Claude Opus 5. Claude Mythos 5.1 is the restricted sibling. Anthropic says its Cyber Verification Program will include Mythos; do not describe that future enrollment as broadly available today.
- Astra is publicly available. OpenAI’s launch evaluations include its Daybreak safeguards, but the current trusted-access documentation says reduced refusals on Astra are unavailable to most Daybreak customers. “Astra has a Daybreak Blue tier” overstates the present product.
- Gemini 3.8 Flash is public; Gemini 3.8 Flash Cyber is gated. Access to the cyber variant goes through Google DeepMind’s Fairwind program.
For security-sensitive procurement, model name, safeguard mode, eligibility, fallback behavior, and audit trail belong in the same record as price and quality.
A routing decision you can defend
| Workload | First model to test | Why | What could reverse the choice |
|---|---|---|---|
| Terminal automation and deployment agents | GPT-6 Astra | Leads AutomationBench and Terminal-Bench 4; lower measured cost and time per task | Fable wins your first-pass completion or cache-heavy traces |
| Scientific coding and hard knowledge work | Claude Fable 5.1 | Leads SciCode, HLE, AA-Briefcase, GDPval-AA, and long-context reasoning | Astra reaches the same accepted answer with fewer tokens and retries |
| High-volume classification, extraction, or lightweight agents | Gemini 3.8 Flash | Lowest list and measured task cost; high throughput | The 12-point composite gap creates expensive review or failure |
| Existing Gemini 3.7 workloads | Keep 3.7 in the test | 3.8 is stronger but slower and more expensive per measured task | The two-point gain materially improves completion |
| Restricted offensive-security research | The approved gated program | Access and safeguards determine what can run | Eligibility, region, logging, or fallback policy fails procurement |
Run the comparison with one row per completed task and at least these seven fields:
model + exact snapshot
effort / reasoning setting
uncached, cached, and output tokens
wall-clock time
retry count
human review minutes
accepted result: yes / noThen calculate:
cost per accepted task =
(token cost + retry cost + review labor) / accepted tasksThat number is harder to market and easier to budget.
The decision after the rerun
On September 5, the provocative line was “same price, 2.7x the bill.” On September 9, the cleaner line is same independent score, 2.34x the measured task cost. The update weakens none of the procurement lesson; it makes it sharper.
Use Fable 5.1 when its knowledge, scientific, or long-context edge changes the outcome. Use Astra when automation performance, concision, and time-to-completion dominate. Use Gemini 3.8 Flash when throughput economics matter and your acceptance tests tolerate the quality gap. Keep Gemini 3.7 in the bake-off until 3.8’s extra reasoning earns its extra bill.
And date every benchmark. Four days was enough to change the headline.
Originally published September 5, 2026. Materially updated September 9, 2026 for Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index v4.3, current task-cost and token data, the Gemini 3.8 versus 3.7 comparison, and corrected cyber-access language.
Further reading
- Artificial Analysis: Claude Fable 5.1
- Artificial Analysis: GPT-6 Astra
- Artificial Analysis: Gemini 3.8 Flash
- Anthropic: Claude Fable 5.1
- Anthropic: Claude Mythos
- OpenAI API pricing
- OpenAI: GPT-6 Astra safety overview
- OpenAI: trusted access for cyber
- Google: Gemini 3.8 Flash and Gemini 3.8 Flash Cyber
- Gemini API pricing
- Google DeepMind: Fairwind
Continue learning with these courses
Sources and Further Reading
- Artificial Analysis: Claude Fable 5.1artificialanalysis.ai
- Artificial Analysis: GPT-6 Astraartificialanalysis.ai
- Artificial Analysis: Gemini 3.8 Flashartificialanalysis.ai
- Anthropic: Claude Fable 5.1anthropic.com
- Anthropic: Claude Mythosanthropic.com
- Anthropic: API pricingplatform.claude.com
- OpenAI: API pricingdevelopers.openai.com
- OpenAI: GPT-6 Astra safety overviewopenai.com
- OpenAI: trusted access for cyberhelp.openai.com
- Google: Gemini 3.8 Flash and Gemini 3.8 Flash Cyberblog.google
- Google: Gemini API pricingai.google.dev
- Google DeepMind: Fairwind programdeepmind.google
Stay ahead with AI insights
Get practical AI tips, new course announcements, and career strategies delivered weekly.
Stay ahead with AI insights
The signup form opens as soon as this page finishes loading. If it does not appear — for example if JavaScript is unavailable — email us and we will subscribe you.